metrehelp.org

Phonology

Sound lab

Pitch, loudness and syllable length in recordings of Greek verse, alongside your own voice.

Phonology

6. Sound lab · 1 of 7

Seeing a voice

A recording can be turned into a picture. The picture shows, moment by moment, how loud the voice is, how high it is, and which vowel or consonant it is making. Every picture on this page also plays. Press the play button under it, or click anywhere on the picture, and a thin line moves across it in time with the sound.

The recordings are the site’s own. One is David Chamberlain’s reading of the opening of the Iliad, a human voice reading in a restored ancient pronunciation. The others are the synthetic tracks that the site uses to sing its examples. A synthetic track is made by a computer from the written text, so it shows a model of the accent, not evidence for it.

The program behind the pictures

The pictures were made with Praat. Praat is a free program for analysing speech, written by Paul Boersma and David Weenink at the University of Amsterdam.[1] Phoneticians all over the world use it to measure recordings. Here it was run through parselmouth, which lets the Python programming language call Praat directly.[2]

This tab explains what the pictures show. The next tab follows Chamberlain through the first two hundred lines of Iliad 1, line by line. The tabs after it compare other readers, measure the pitch accent and the length of syllables, and let you record your own voice.

Five rows in every picture

Measured Each picture has the same five rows, from top to bottom.

  1. Syllables. The top row is a strip of labels. Each label is one syllable of the scansion, with its long or short sign, placed over the stretch of sound it occupies. For the synthetic tracks the times are exact, because the site made the sound. For Chamberlain they were measured.
  2. Waveform. The waveform is the pressure of the air as it changes from moment to moment. Loud vowels are the wide parts. A stop such as [p] or [t] shows as a short gap, because the mouth is closed for a moment. A hissing sound such as [s] is a dense, narrow fuzz.
  3. Spectrogram. In a spectrogram, time runs from left to right and frequency from bottom to top. The darker a spot, the more energy the sound has at that frequency at that moment.[3] The pictures here use a short analysis window of 5 milliseconds, which gives what is called a broad-band spectrogram.[4] In a broad-band spectrogram the dark horizontal bands are the formants. Formants are the resonances of the mouth and throat, and they are what makes one vowel sound different from another. The coloured dots are Praat’s estimates of the first three formants, which are called F1, F2 and F3.
  4. Pitch. This row shows the fundamental frequency, written F0. F0 is the number of times a second that the vocal folds open and close, and the ear hears it as how high the voice is. Praat finds it by autocorrelation: it compares the sound with copies of itself shifted by different amounts, and keeps the shift that matches best.[5] This is the row that matters most here, because the Greek accent was a pitch accent. A pitch accent is an accent made by raising the voice, not by making the syllable louder or longer.[6] The scale is logarithmic, because the ear hears pitch as ratios. A fifth, for example, is the ratio 3 : 2 wherever it starts.
  5. Intensity. The bottom row shows the intensity in decibels, which is how loud the voice is from moment to moment. A stress accent shows in this row and in the length of the syllable, but a pitch accent need not show here at all.[7] Whether the Greek accent also changed the loudness of the voice is one of the questions of the Accent page.

How to play a picture

Press ▶ under a picture to hear it, and press again to pause. A line moves across all five rows while the sound plays. Click or tap any point of the picture to play from that moment. With a keyboard, move to the picture with the Tab key. Then Space plays or pauses, the left and right arrows step back or forward by half a second, and Home returns to the start.

Chamberlain, Iliad 1.1

Praat picture of Iliad 1.1 read by David Chamberlain: syllables, waveform, spectrogram with formants, pitch and intensity
μῆνιν ἄειδε θεὰ Πηληϊάδεω Ἀχιλῆος, read by David Chamberlain. The pause after θεὰ is the caesura. The pitch rises through μῆ- and ἄ- and falls away through -ειδε. The long -ῆ- of Ἀχιλῆος carries a rise and a fall of its own.

Three things are worth watching. First, the reader’s voice covers a wide range. Over the first 52 lines his syllables span about fourteen semitones, from the 5th to the 95th centile, as the Pitch accent tab measures. That is twice the fifth, seven semitones, that Dionysius of Halicarnassus allows to the melody of speech.[8] The accented syllables sit higher than the unaccented ones on average, but not every one does.

Second, the pitch moves in glides, not in steps. Speech glides from one pitch to the next, while singing moves by fixed intervals.[9]

Third, the intensity stays within about 10 dB across the line, except at the pause. The movements of pitch are not matched by movements of loudness.

The synthetic Sappho track

Praat picture of the synthetic sung Sappho fr. 1.1
ποικιλόθρον’ ἀθανάτ’ Ἀφρόδιτα, the site’s synthetic sung track ∿. The dotted lines are the two notes the track is built on, D3 and A3, a fifth apart. The accented syllables sit on the upper note.

The synthetic voice does exactly what it was told. Every acute is a level high note a fifth above the low one. The syllable after it glides down, and everything else stays low. Set beside the real reader, this is a model of the written accents, not evidence for how they sounded, and it sings where Chamberlain speaks.

The fuzzy background of the spectrogram is the lyre drone and the echo of the room, which were added to the mix. For the same reason Praat’s pitch tracker loses the voice in several syllables. That is why its voicing threshold was lowered for these tracks.

Narrow band and broad band

The word μῆνιν in a narrow-band and a broad-band spectrogram
μῆνιν, read by Chamberlain, shown twice. A 30 ms window resolves the harmonics; a 5 ms window resolves the formants. The line moves across both pictures at once.

The choice of window decides what a spectrogram shows.[4] A long window of 30 ms gives a narrow-band spectrogram. In it the thin horizontal lines are the harmonics of the voice, which are whole multiples of F0. When the voice rises on μῆ-, every line rises, and the gaps between them widen.

A short window of 5 ms gives the broad-band picture on the right. It smears the harmonics into the broad bands of the formants. The formants hardly move within a vowel, but they jump at the consonants.

The slow demonstrations

Praat picture of the slow synthetic Iliad 1.1
Il. 1.1 at half speed, the Start-here track ∿. A short syllable lasts 0.5 s.
Praat picture of the slow synthetic Sappho 1.1
Sappho 1.1 at half speed, the Start-here track ∿.

These two are the cleanest pictures on the page, because they have no drone. Each long syllable lasts exactly twice as long as a short one, and the pitch sits on only two notes. They show what the signs mean, not how a Greek spoke.

Notes

  1. ^ Boersma and Weenink 2021.
  2. ^ Jadoul et al. 2018.
  3. ^ Boersma and Weenink 2021, § ‘Intro 3.1’.
  4. ^ a b Boersma and Weenink 2021, § ‘Intro 3.2’.
  5. ^ Boersma 1993.
  6. ^ Devine and Stephens 1994, p. 211; Allen 1968, p. 106.
  7. ^ Devine and Stephens 1994, p. 211.
  8. ^ Allen 1968, p. 109.
  9. ^ Allen 1968, p. 111.
Picture credits on this page
  1. Behind the title: Euripides, Orestes 338–344, from a choral song, with vocal and instrumental notation above the words: papyrus written around 200 BC at Hermopolis. Vienna, Austrian National Library. Austrian National Library, via the World Digital Library · Public domain · via Wikimedia Commons · background removed